Unlike health promotional activities that are targeted to select populations based on cost-effectiveness research, advance directives and advance care planning have been recommended for everyone. This is a limitation to the policy as recommended by the Patient Self-Determination Act of 1991 and the Joint Accreditation of Health Care Organizations, as it has led to including a standard set of questions at hospital admission without much information or understanding.


Unlike health promotional activities that are targeted to select populations based on cost-effectiveness research, advance directives and advance care planning have been recommended for everyone. This is a limitation to the policy as recommended by the Patient Self-Determination Act of 1991 and the Joint Accreditation of Health Care Organizations, as it has led to including a standard set of questions at hospital admission without much information or understanding.

We usually think of doing advance care planning with patients who are at higher risk for decisional incapacity. You should consider having a conversation about this with patients with the following conditions:

  • at risk for strokes (e.g., those with hypertension)
  • experiencing early dementia
  • engaging in risky behavior that is associated with head trauma and coma (e.g., motorcyclists, riding in cars without seat belts)
  • experiencing severe, recurrent psychiatric illnesses
  • terminal illness